Article

What to do about quiet inaction

Why finance leaders should build change management skills in their teams
Authors
Published

17 November 2026

Knowing the numbers is where a finance business partner’s work begins. The work that creates value is spotting the problem in the figures, shaping a workable solution, and persuading stakeholders to act on it, because an insight that nobody acts on cannot create value. Building those abilities in finance teams is therefore a central task for every finance leader, and one that grows more urgent as technology takes over more of the data work. 


Finance training builds the acumen to turn data into insight. But moving people to act on it, when it effectively means changing how they work, calls for a different skill set that most finance professionals are never taught: change management. This article introduces change management in the context of finance business partnering and shows how finance practitioners can: 

  • distinguish between cognitive, emotional, and relational change resistance 
  • identify the emotional drivers of resistance with the SCARF model 
  • build a plan to overcome resistance with the ADKAR model

Understanding change resistance 


Whenever we propose something new, a different way of working, a new process, a change to how the business plans or reports, we will meet resistance. Always. This is not a sign that the idea is bad or that the stakeholders are difficult. Change resistance is a natural, predictable human reaction to anything that disrupts the familiar. People are wired to prefer the known over the unknown, even when the known is demonstrably broken. 


Take a typical example. The analysis shows that the annual budgeting process is consuming months of effort and producing numbers that are outdated before the ink is dry. The obvious solution: replace it with a leaner, driver-based rolling forecast. On paper, everyone wins; in practice, the proposal is met with folded arms, polite nodding, and quiet inaction. Why? Often, the root cause of the inertia lies in at least one of three areas identified by Rick Maurer, a globally recognised thought leader on organisational change, as cognitive resistance, emotional resistance, and relational resistance. 


Cognitive resistance translates into “I don’t get it”. It is caused by people’s lack of understanding – this happens when information and reasoning are lacking. 


Emotional resistance translates into “I don’t like it” and is the emotional reaction to what is being proposed – this happens when the change triggers fear of losing status, control, or other valued attributes of the status quo. 


Relational resistance translates into “I don’t like you” and is caused by distrust in the messenger – this happens due to interpersonal aversion based on history, broken promises, or the group you represent (finance, head office, consultants).

Figure 1: Sources of change resistance

Each source of resistance requires its own remedy. Cognitive resistance is cured by clear facts, a compelling case, and answers to what and why. Emotional resistance is cured by listening, acknowledging what people stand to lose, and showing what is in it for them. Relational resistance is cured by rebuilding the relationship – owning past mistakes, demonstrating reliability, and sometimes letting someone with more credibility carry the message. 


A common mistake among finance professionals is to approach all resistance as if it were cognitive – emphasising arguments and extending explanations. If the source of the resistance is emotional or relational, then more explaining rarely helps and can backfire, because we end up sounding patronising. 


Persistent change resistance rarely springs from a lack of understanding. Often, the cause of resistance is an emotional threat response. The difficulty lies in identifying what drives that emotion. The SCARF model, developed by David Rock, co-founder of the NeuroLeadership Institute, can help us find the answer. SCARF is an acronym for five social domains where the brain registers threat or reward: status, certainty, autonomy, relatedness, and fairness. When any of these is threatened, the brain responds much as it would to a physical threat: it goes on the defensive. And a defensive stakeholder is unlikely to adopt your proposal, however sound the numbers behind it are. 


Now let us return to the budgeting proposal and look at it through the SCARF lens. When we as finance professionals arrive with something new, the business is likely to see it as a threat to several SCARF domains at once: 


Status – your sense of standing relative to others: The department head who has run the budgeting process for a decade hears that their way of working is obsolete. Their expertise, and with it their standing, feels devalued. 


Certainty – your ability to predict what comes next: Nobody knows exactly what the new process will look like, what it means for their targets, or whether they will master it. People read ambiguity as danger. 


Autonomy – your sense of control and choice over your work: A new process designed by finance and imposed on the business strips people of control over how they work. Few things trigger resistance faster. 


Relatedness – your sense of belonging and being on the same side: The new rolling forecast scraps the quarterly budget workshops. What finance sees as waste removed, the regional managers experience as losing a valued ritual with close colleagues. 


Fairness – your perception that outcomes and exchanges are just: If some departments feel the new targets or the transition burden hit them harder than others, the whole change is tainted, regardless of its overall merit. 


The task for finance leaders is to equip their teams to flip each perceived threat into a perceived reward, one SCARF domain at a time: 


Status: involve the department head as a co-designer whose experience shapes the new process. 


Certainty: communicate early, often, and concretely about what will happen and when. 


Autonomy: give the business genuine choices in how the change is implemented in their area. 


Relatedness: frame it as a joint effort with a shared goal. 


Fairness: be transparent about how burdens and benefits are distributed.

Figure 2: Reactions to change

Only when people can see themselves benefiting from the change, rather than being threatened by it, can we overcome the resistance and ensure that our insights lead to changed behaviour and, thereby, impact for the business. Analysing the three sources of resistance (cognitive, emotional, relational) and the SCARF reactions helps finance teams diagnose the resistance. It tells us where the perceived threat sits and why people are pushing back, but it does not tell us what to do about it. And diagnosis without treatment changes nothing. This is where ADKAR comes in. 


From resistance to adoption 


Understanding why people resist is only half the job. The other half is doing something about it, stakeholder by stakeholder. This is where the ADKAR framework developed by Prosci founder Jeff Hiatt earns its place in the finance business partner’s toolkit and where finance leaders should build that capability in their teams. ADKAR stands for awareness, desire, knowledge, ability, and reinforcement. It offers a structured way to move each stakeholder from resistance to adoption, describing the five stages every individual must move through before a change can truly stick. Every stage applies to one person at a time. That matters, because a change plan that treats ‘the business’ as one audience will fail the moment it meets a sceptical department head.

Figure 3: The ADKAR model

To make the five stages easier to act on, we group them into three phases: incubate the change (awareness and desire), teach the change (knowledge and ability), and sustain the change (reinforcement). 


Incubate: create awareness and desire 


Before anyone can change, they will need to know a change is coming and want to be part of it. These are two different things, and finance professionals routinely conflate them. We announce the new budgeting process in an email, attach a slide deck, and assume the job is done. But awareness without desire produces compliance at best and quiet sabotage at worst. Finance leaders need to train finance professionals to build both. 


Take the budgeting example. Creating awareness means explaining, early and in person, why the current process is broken – the weeks of manual consolidation, the numbers that are outdated before management even sees them, the gaming of targets. Creating desire means translating the change into personal benefit for each stakeholder. For the sales director, the new process means fewer late-night template exercises and targets that reflect market reality. For the department head who is worried about their status, it means a seat at the table in designing the new process rather than having it imposed. You are answering one question for every stakeholder: what is in it for me? Until they have an answer they believe, you have not incubated anything. 


Teach: build knowledge and ability 


Once people accept the premise and find a personal motivation, they need to learn the new way of working. Again, these are two distinct steps. Knowledge is knowing what to do differently. Ability is actually being able to do it. A workshop can create knowledge, but only practice, time, and support can create ability. 


For the new budgeting process, knowledge might mean training sessions on the new driver-based logic, walkthroughs of the new templates, and clear documentation of who does what and when. Ability means running a parallel cycle where people try the new process with support available, accepting that the first round will be slower and messier than the old routine, and pairing less confident users with colleagues who have picked it up quickly. This is where many finance-led changes collapse: we train once, declare victory, and then get frustrated when adoption lags. People need time to practise, so finance leaders and change agents should build that time into the plan from the start. 


Sustain: reinforce the change 


The final stage is the one finance most often skips. Going live does not end the pull of old habits, and the moment pressure hits, people tend to revert to the spreadsheet they know. Reinforcement is how you prevent that. 


In practice, reinforcement means celebrating early wins publicly, for example by showing the management team how the first driver-based forecast caught a demand shift that the old budget would have missed. It means measuring adoption, not just output: are people actually using the new templates, or rebuilding the old ones in the shadows? It means removing the old tools entirely, because as long as the legacy templates exist, they will be used. And it means leaders visibly working the new way themselves, because nothing kills a change faster than a CFO who asks for the old report. 


Motivation gets a change started. Reinforcement is what turns it into lasting behavioural change, and that is how we should measure the success of our work. 


The capability finance cannot afford to ignore 


Here is the uncomfortable truth: most finance professionals are never taught change management. We are trained in accounting standards, financial modelling, and analytics. We are hired for our ability to make sense of numbers. And for a long time, that was enough, because turning data into insight was the scarce skill. 


But that is no longer the case. AI and modern technology are rapidly taking over the data crunching, the reconciliations, the variance analysis, even the first draft of the insight itself. What machines cannot do, however, is sit across from a sceptical sales director, understand why the new process feels like a threat to their autonomy, and patiently work towards their ownership of it. That is, in essence, human work – and it is becoming the core of the finance business partner role. 


So, the value of a finance professional is shifting towards making the insight matter. While data crunching is increasingly automated, the work of getting people to act is not, and it may never be. The finance organisations that embrace this change are poised to generate the most impact. 


That makes change management a career-defining skill, and a core one. Learn to spot resistance before it hardens. Learn to reframe threats as rewards. Learn to build awareness, create desire, teach the new way, and reinforce it until it sticks. Our job is done when something changes for the better, and the sooner finance teams build these capabilities, the more the business will rely on them.

Related0 4